I loved Hunger Games, the first book by Suzanne Collins. I loved it a lot, we even went steady for a bit. It, for me, was the American version of Battle Royale by Koushun Takami- a incredible book and fantastic Japanese film, as well as a series of manga. Waiting for the sequel was like waiting for my name to be called at the Quarter Quell.
Whatever I had braced myself for in the second book wasn't enough. I thought I had a good imagination, but kudos to Collins for blowing my expectations out of the water without jumping the shark. I won't spoil the book for you, so I won't talk about the plot, but wow. Just wow, Ms. Collins.
Katniss, Peeta, Gale, Prim, and all your favorites are back (sadly no Rue, but she gets a fitting tribute). The triangle that was brewing in the first book is more fleshed out in Catching Fire, but it is never the focus, which is a relief. Unlike other love triangles (Edward/Bella/Jacob or Stefan/Elena/Damon) there's no clear front runner for me. I feel that Katniss belongs with Gale, but Peeta is one of my all time favorite characters that I can't see how Katniss doesn't love him madly. Only Katniss is not me, she's not interested in getting married and having babies. It occurs to me now that Katniss already has raised and taken care of a family, her mom and Prim, and I don't think she can ever truly give Peeta what he needs or deserves.
Something in Katniss is broken, but it's this very aspect that is her saving grace. The death of her father, her mother's inability to cope in the beginning, risking her life to feed and protect her sister, all these events have left a deep mark on Katniss. But they also prepared her to win the Hunger Games, to save Peeta. I don't know that I want Katniss healed, a Katniss that was eager to marry and raise children would be a tragic character departure. Still, I want a happy ending for Peeta....
My solution? Prim for Peeta! It'll be very Little Women, Jo and Laurie can't be together because Jo isn't right for Laurie, and then eventually he falls in love with Amy. Perfect solution for Prim and Peeta.
I know this hasn't been much of a review, but anything I say will be a spoiler, so if you even kinda, sorta liked Hunger Games, Catching Fire will blow your book loving mind. It's a better, richer, more complex novel. There's lots of Katniss, lots of Peeta. District 12 is wonderfully brought to life again, becoming another character in its own right. You'll laugh, you'll cry, you'll hold your breath and almost pass out until you remember to breathe again.
Catching Fire gets a rating of: Midnight Read.
*Dear FCC, despite the fact that I am rigorously recommending this book to anyone that will stand still long enough to listen, I bought the copy of the book myself. Suzanne Collins and her publishers did not solicit my opinion, nor do they return my emails or calls. They do not acknowledge my fan collages or my repeated requests to have my apartment be mentioned as District 0. The two neighborhood children I sent them as tributes were promptly returned, and the proper authorities were called on me.
Countdown to 2025: Day 22
10 hours ago
I didn't like CF very much. It was awkwardly written and I hated that Katniss became so stupid in it. Plus, I don't like the love triangle. I'm firmly in the Team Katniss category - I don't think she should end up with either guys. They're both wrong for her.
ReplyDeleteAmanda- I agree that Katniss is probably destined to be alone, but I think Gale is the more compatible guy for her, just because they're very similar people- although his character could use a lot more fleshing out. I actually really liked the flow of Catching Fire, and I didn't think the love triangle was too prominent, I don't even think the rivalry between Gale and Peeta is needed. The real obstacle that keeps Katniss from Peeta (and from Gale) is her very nature.
ReplyDeleteAmanda- I'm linking your review of the book to give a more balanced look at the book (since mine was a bit of a lovefest). I think you brought up some interesting points that I didn't cover, and I agree that there were leaps forward in time that were a bit jarring. So, I urge other blog readers to check out The Zen Leaf site for a different take on Catching Fire (and feel free to leave a link if you've reviewed any books discussed on my site):
ReplyDeletehttp://zenleaf.blogspot.com/2009/09/catching-fire-by-suzanne-collins.html
Love your review, Kate! I read this a few days ago and can't put it down! I literally tuned out everything around me...
ReplyDelete